Going "Green" with Autophagy as Your Evolutionary Health Care Plan
Look around at the world today and you will see something gone wrong. Increased rates of heart diseases, all types of cancers, fears of pandemic flus and other degenerative conditions becoming more prevalent such as arthritis, auto-immune disorders, and alzheimers.
Is this just part of a wake-up call on an evolutionary level?
Where did We go Wrong?
Today’s environment that we live in (including the foods that we eat) is far from the natural conditions that people lived in long ago. That is not to say we all need to move back into caves and hunt for food, but we should focus on the more important recent (esp the last hundred years) changes that are taking our health in the wrong direction.
Those big changes include:
- Rancid Fats/Oils/Trans Fats in Processed Foods
- Sugars/HFCS in Processed Foods (disaster for the liver)
- Lack of Daily Exercise/Activity/Movement
- Calorie Excess/Overload (processed foods high in calorie density)
- Hormones and Pesticides in Food (dairy and meat especially)
- Exposure to Environmental Chemicals (pollution, plastics, medications)
- Drugs (legal or illegal), Smoking, Alcohol abuse
- Lack of Essential Vitamins/Minerals (esp fat soluble) in diet
- High Stress Lifestyles/Lack of Sleep
While I am not going to ever point out just one thing to blame for our sad state of health today, they all play a part. We need to start looking at the damage being done on the body as a whole and how it effects us at the cellular level. Optimizing health at the cellular level is vital.
For example, what is cancer? Essentially it is a bunch of cells gone bad and destructive. If left unchecked it will continue to damage other cells and create more and more “cells gone bad”. Do this in your lung and you have lung cancer, in your brain and you have brain cancer, etc.
So in our modern goal of health awareness and reducing risks of disease, we should be looking to focus our efforts on maintaining health at the cellular level (which means creating less destruction and increasing repair/rebuilding).
The Only Known way to Live Longer/Healthier
Scientists have known for a long time that there is really only one proven way to increase the lifespan of animals in test conditions (as well as improve health in humans). This is what is known as Calorie Restriction (or CR). Here is an excerpt from a recent article in the New York Times on the calorie restriction experiment:
A curious aspect of the Calerie project, though, is that it is not meant to study weight loss or if one type of diet is better than another. Instead, Calerie is investigating how (and if) a spartan diet affects the aging process and its associated diseases. To the Calerie researchers, these are quite distinct. The aging process, which researchers sometimes call “primary” or “intrinsic” aging, refers to the damage that ordinarily accumulates in our cells as we grow older, a natural condition that seems to have limited the maximal lifespan of humans to 120 years. Diseases that accompany the aging process — often called “secondary aging” — are those afflictions increasingly prevalent in the elderly, like cancer, diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
There seems little doubt that calorie restriction can have significant effects on secondary aging. A recent spate of papers in some of the world’s leading medical journals demonstrate that in small studies, human subjects following such diets experience astounding drops in cardiovascular risk factors; a forthcoming review on cancer risks in animals with such diets, moreover, suggests a stark correlation — fewer calories mean fewer tumors.
Fontana connected his point to his continuing observations of some Calorie Restriction Society members. “In terms of cardiovascular diseases — the No. 1 cause of death; 4 out of 10 people die of it in the U.S. and Europe — we know that they will not die of cardiovascular death,” Fontana said. His subjects have cholesterol around 160, blood pressure around 100 over 60, high HDL, low triglycerides and very low levels of inflammation. “So these people won’t develop these diseases,” he said. “And I think that’s an important finding. Because every day doctors are publishing hundreds of papers on circulation research and medications that are lowering blood pressure or cholesterol by a small bit. And here we have such a powerful intervention that is basically cleaning out the arteries.”
Calorie Restriction is a natural way in which the body can produce less damage and be more resistant to damage at the cellular level. All this leads to a healthier and longer life. Also it seems that there is another process going on that helps to repair the damage due to aging. This could hold the key to helping not only treat people with diseases, but also help people live longer (by slowing down the destructive aging process).
Cell Death and Recycling
More and more light is being put into how the cells can “recycle” their own damaged parts and create a new and healthy cell in the process. This is what is known as autophagy and could be one of the keys to living longer and healthier!
Here’s a good summary from the University of Florida Health news on UF scientists reveal how dietary restriction cleans cells:
During the aging process, free radicals . – highly reactive byproducts of our cells’ respiration – wreak havoc on our cellular machinery. Mitochondria, the tiny power plants that keep a cell functioning, are especially vulnerable to this type of damage. The effects can be disastrous – if malfunctioning mitochondria aren’t removed, they begin to spew out suicidal proteins that prompt the entire cell to die. Cell death, on a whole-body scale, is what aging is all about.
Fortunately, younger cells are adept at reducing, recycling and rebuilding. In this process, damaged mitochondria are quickly swallowed up and degraded. The broken down pieces are then recycled and used to build new mitochondria. However, older cells are less adept at this process, so damaged mitochondria tend to accumulate and contribute to aging.
“Cell survival is dependent upon the ability of the cell to reduce and recycle by a mechanism called autophagy,” said William Dunn Jr., Ph.D., a professor of anatomy and cell biology in UF’s College of Medicine and senior author of the study,
and more from this really good article in Scientific American on How Cells Clean House:
Mitochondria, for instance, are the organelles primarily responsible for generating energy within a cell, and they can send signals to other parts of the cell that initiate apoptosis, or cellular suicide.
Cells induce apoptosis for a variety of reasons, all more or less for the greater good of the organism. For example, the body continually generates more cells than it needs, and they must be eliminated. An aging cell that has ceased functioning efficiently may kill itself to make room for younger, more robust cells. A cell that switches from normal growth to cancerous proliferation can also be induced to commit suicide, making apoptosis one of the most important built-in barriers against cancer. Apoptosis depends on a complex series of cellular events, rigorously orchestrated by numerous protein signals, and so the death of the cell by apoptosis is considered to be a programmed event.
But a faulty mitochondrion can wreak havoc if it sets off apoptosis at the wrong time. Among the by-products of a functioning mitochondrion are reactive oxygen species (ROS)—oxygen ions and other oxygen-based molecular fragments. Working with such volatile chemicals often causes mitochondria to leak some of their contents, including the signaling proteins that initiate apoptosis. In other words, a minor flaw in a small part of the cell can lead, inadvertently, to the death of the entire cell. The accidental cellular demise of a few skin cells might not be a big deal, but such a loss of memory neurons in the brain would definitely spell trouble.
The escape of such large amounts of ROS poses a cancer threat, because ROS that reach the nucleus may induce malignant changes in genes. Once again, autophagy can come to the rescue, removing the dysfunctional mitochondria from the cell. Eileen White of Rutgers University believes that autophagy also mitigates genome damage in cancer cells, thereby helping to prevent new tumors from forming.
Most people take it for granted that many diseases become more frequent with age, including cancer and the degeneration of neurons. The reason, in part, may be a decline in the efficiency of autophagy. According to Ana Maria Cuervo of the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, the current thinking is that cellular systems, including autophagy, undergo a steady loss of function with age.
Recall that a restricted food supply—incipient starvation—speeds up autophagy.
The programmed cell death/self-suicide of a cell, otherwise known as apoptosis, is a good thing in some cases. While you don’t want all your cells to die off, you definitely don’t want the cancerous cells gone bad sticking around and creating more damage. It could be summed up that a defective apoptosis system is a big reason for the progression of cancerous cells in a body. If left unchecked, the cancerous cells spread and create more. A functioning apoptosis system would call for the cancerous cells to commit suicide and stop the progression.
So it seems that autophagy through various pathways can not only help stop new progression of cancerous cells, but may also help improve apotosis signaling through healthy mitochondria. Add this to a continual process of healthy cell repair and “going green” (recycling) at the cell level may be the real fountain of youth.
Understanding Aging to Reduce Diseases
Researchers are now currently looking for a pharmaceutical treatment to increase autophagy in healthy cells and apoptosis in cancerous ones (although more is not always better and with every treatment seems to come more negative side effects). By looking at the real source of the problem (aging), evolutionary solutions can be seen in helping people with diseases associated with it.
from this recent article in the Boston Globe on Age-old woes, New Tactic.
The drugs in Sirtris’s pipeline are aimed at treating two diseases associated with aging: type 2 diabetes and cancer. The drugs target sirtuins, the enzymes identified by Gaurente and others as regulating cell metabolism.
Much of the discussion at the Harvard lifespan conference centered on sirtuin modulators, which appear to provide the same benefits as calorie restriction (CR) – a practice enthusiasts believe will extend their life spans. Their faith is based on the results of studies with yeast, flies, and primates.
Resveratrol, found most abundantly in red wine and Japanese knotweed, is the best-known sirtuin modulator. Many scientists speculate that the resveratrol in red wine is behind the “French paradox,’’ the low incidence of heart disease in the French despite their love for fatty foods.
Message is Simple: Eat Less (and Eat Real Foods)
While researchers are trying to come up with patented pharmaceutical versions to enhance autophagy (and they will probably not be cheap either), we already have those systems built in if we send the right signals to help increase their function. Namely through a “restricted food supply”, like the “feast-famine” environments that our bodies were designed to survive.
While CR is certainly not the most realistic nor enjoyable solution for many, there is still many of the same benefits found with Intermittent Fasting (or IF). The benefits of IF is you can also maintain lean bodyweight (muscle) while burning fat and still enjoy eating. Plus, it is the cheapest way I know of that you can reduce your risks for degenerative diseases!
So while health care costs are going through the roof and medical treatments are too expensive for many to afford, maybe it is time we all start to realize the evolutionary plan for the body to help heal itself. It costs nothing more than just personal awareness into how you eat effects your own health. Eat less and eat more “real foods” is the best advice I think we all need to take to heart (and tell others to do as well). The bonus is if you eat mainly real foods anyways, that it is hard to actually overeat in the first place!
More related quotes and articles on Autophagy
Aging denotes a postmaturational deterioration of cells and organisms with the passage of time, an increased vulnerability to challenges and prevalence of age-associated diseases, and a decreased ability to survive. Causes of this deterioration may be found in an enhanced production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and oxidative damage and incomplete “housekeeping.” Caloric restriction is the most robust anti-aging intervention known so far. Similar beneficial effects on median and maximum life span were obtained by feeding animals a 40%-reduced diet or by every-other-day ad libitum feeding. In both instances, animals are forced to spend a great part of their time in a state of fasting and activated autophagy. …. Several pieces of evidence show that autophagy is involved in aging and is an essential part of the anti-aging mechanism of caloric restriction.
As a consequence of the induction of autophagy during short periods of fasting, animals experience diurnal rhythms of autophagy in concert with their circadian cycle.
Overview of the importance of autophagy and diseases (which still shows there is much we don’t know as well)
Precise regulation of autophagy is necessary to maintain metabolic equilibrium, immune homeostasis, delineate cell fate and influence host cell responses to cytosolic pathogens. A growing number of studies have implicated that inactivation of autophagy-selective responses contributes to inflammatory disorders, neurodegeneration and cancer, but the precise steps at which disease-associated autophagy-related (ATG) genes affect autophagy pathways is unknown at present
and how some viruses actually attack (and inhibit) autophagy/apoptosis
Viral subversion and inhibition of host cell autophagy has been documented for several viruses. In this issue of Cell Host & Microbe,Gannagé et al. (2009) show that the influenza virus M2 integral membrane protein blocks autophagosome maturation, significantly affecting host cell apoptosis.
and Intermittent fasting alleviates neuropathic disease
Charcot-Marie-Tooth type 1A (CMT1A) neuropathies linked to the misexpression of peripheral myelin protein 22 (PMP22) are progressive demyelinating disorders of the peripheral nervous system. In this study we asked whether dietary restriction by intermittent fasting (IF) could alleviate the neuropathic phenotype in the Trembler J (TrJ) mouse model of CMT1A. Our results show that neuropathic mice kept on a five month long IF regimen had improved locomotor performance compared to ad libitum (AL) fed littermates. The functional benefits of this dietary intervention are associated with an increased expression of myelin proteins combined with a thicker myelin sheath, less redundant basal lamina, and a reduction in aberrant Schwann cell proliferation. These morphological improvements are accompanied by a decrease in PMP22 protein aggregates, and enhanced expression of cytosolic chaperones and constituents of the autophagy-lysosomal pathway.
- Resveratrol, Red Wine, Diabetes, Cancer and Longevity
- The Longevity Gene Sirt1 – CR, Fasting and Aging Diseases
- Weight training and Autophagy at Conditioning Research
- Cellular Autophagy from Artur De Vany
- Autophagy required for calorie restriction benefits? from Fight Aging
- How dietary restriction cleans cells from U of Fl
- How cells clean house from Scientific American (PDF)
Get Daily Updates on Facebook/Twitter
**NEW** As of 2012 I am getting more active daily on my new "2 Meal Mike" Facebook and Twitter accounts. Come join in on the fun and say Hi!
About the Author
"2 Meal" Mike (O'Donnell) is a fitness trainer and coach promoting the simple 2 Meal lifestyle philosophy for lasting results. The IF Life was created in 2008 and strives to help people break free from complicated and be lean/fit with minimal effort (and maximum happiness). Get all new blog posts sent to you by entering your email below.(or get RSS feed here)
Comments/Discussion
Got a comment or insight you want to add to this topic? Then please feel free to continue the discussion below. Please use your real name and not just your website (I will remove spam comments).
{10 Comments. Read them below or add one}










I’ve read about Calorie Restriction (the CR Way, I think) and sometimes I wonder if CR is not actually restriction, but just the way we are supposed to eat. I’ve seen the daily menu of some CR practitioners and honestly I eat the same, if not less than some of these folks. And, I don’t feel restricted. I think CR could be marketed better without using the word “restriction.”. Maybe?
Like or Dislike:
1
0
[Reply]
Here are some of the rules I follow:
1. Avoid trans fats/hydrogenated fats/margarine etc.
2. Treat desert as desert and not as the main meal.
3. Eat less.
4. Follow the rule – eat breakfast like a king, lunch like a prince and dinner like a pauper.
5. Move, train and play.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
[Reply]
Mike I am wondering how long a fast might have to be to “kick” in autophagy? I am going 16-18 hours a day with no food.
Thanks for your hard work here, it is very much appreciated .
James
Like or Dislike:
0
0
[Reply]
barbara Reply:
What was the response to this question?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
[Reply]
Mike OD Reply:
see 2 comments down
Like or Dislike:
0
0
[Reply]
I’ve read many studies that support this idea, and its been proven out in small-scale studies with mice. However, it also flies directly in the face of what heavy bodybuilders do, which is pack on lots of excess mass. This takes calories. I’d maintain that even if that doesn’t make them overfat, they are still overweight.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
[Reply]
Article Update - More links added to bottom of articles for information on autophagy
@ HMama – Yes CR is not the most appealing name, and most that do practice it are also very very skinny (probably more than what most people who also want some muscle are willing to do). But eating less can be beneficial at some level.
@Yavor – Good rules (even if I do eat less during the day and more at night…there is always more than one way to be healthy and happy!)
@James – Autophagy is an ongoing process that declines with age, it doesn’t really turn on or off. But you can “increase” function, which can help people more as they age (not really with younger people who are already running at peak capacity). There has to be a “low food” stress to signal an increase so it starts “consuming itself” at the cell level for energy (and in some cases exercise may do this as well). I’ve read that this is also dependent on one’s bodyfat, because as you fast your body turns to fat for energy. So if you have more fat stored, you are still not signaling enough of a “low food” environment compared to someone who is lower in bodyfat. CR studies are low calories over longer periods of time, compared with IF. So in a sense there is no “magic” number for when does fasting “maximize” autophagy (but maybe more research will be done in the future to determine it). So does one 24 hr fast really signal a large increase in autophagy compared to a 18hr fast? Possibly as it makes sense the longer a fast then the more of a low food stimulus you would create. Does a 3 day fast do more healing? Possibly. Would people with existing conditions need longer low calorie time frames for benefit (like when you hear about people with cancers being treated with weeks of juice fasting)? Possibly again. What about comparing a single 24 hr fast to a daily 18hr fast over time? That I have no information on, but I would like to know as well. Also when talking about the more frequent shorter IF windows you would have to look at the whole calorie load over time and if it is promoting enough of a “low food” stress like CR would. I am really excited to see autophagy getting more and more attention, so hopefully more research will come about from it. research and studies on CR and IF over time. I would love to see more of this type of research being applied into more traditional modern treatments for diseases to help increase repair and recovery. Sorry I went off rambling, but there is more exciting stuff with autophagy on the horizon I have a feeling…..
@Greg – Eating excess calories all the time is still not a great idea, especially as we get older. Excess calories can lead to more oxidation, more free radicals, more wear and tear, downturn of cellular recycling and all that good stuff. Doing short cycles for adding more muscle won’t probably make a huge difference, it’s going to be how is it maintained over the long run. The smartest BB types I know also use cycles of low calories and don’t eat too much to excess otherwise.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
[Reply]
Correct nutrition is certainly one of the most powerful ways to control and transform our health. At least there are now more and more information sources educating people about what correct nutrition actually is. And that’s a good start, but it’s really just the beginning, isn’t it?
There are so many other factors that influence our likelihood of contracting any given disease, and many of them are outside our control. But one that we definitely do have some power over is that of our mindset. I think there’s a lot to be said for the ability of a strong and determined (positive) mind. It’s amazing how people who put a negative spin on everything seem to be so much more plagued by all manner of illness. I’m not saying that a happy or positive person can’t get sick, but it is a possible contributing factor, and certainly one worth giving a go anyway!
Learning to be happy and positive is just like creating any other habit – it takes time and deliberate attention. A good starting point is to become more aware of your thought patterns, and deliberately try to turn around those internal negative responses.
Sorry, have gone way off on a tangent here!
Like or Dislike:
0
0
[Reply]
Interestingly CR is also an effective way to drop weight. But that doesn’t mean starve. CR plus changing of the foods you eat will keep you satisfied for much, much longer while taking in few calories than, say… if you at a Whopper.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
[Reply]
[...] muscle on less dietary protein. By using IF and allowing the body to recycle old junk proteins (remember autophagy?) as well as enzymes, the demand for amino acids through diet could be [...]
Like or Dislike:
0
0